Butea Superba (Red Kwao Krua) is a herb from Thai medicine sometimes thought to be the male equivalent of Pueraria Mirifica, a phytoestrogen known as White Kwao Krua; evidence for Butea Superba for these claims is lacking.
1.
Sources and Composition
1.1
Sources
Butea Superba is one of three herbs with the designation of 'Kwao Krua' in traditional Thai medicine, and is more specifically called 'Red Kwao Krua' with the other relevant herbs being 'White' Kwao Krua (Pueraria Mirifica) and 'Black' Kwao Krua (Mucuna collettii); Butea Superba is visually similar to Pueraria Mirifica.[1]
Butea Superba is a tuber vegetable that has been used for male vitality purposes in Thailand
1.2
Composition
A few components are known, but the active component is not currently known
2.
Pharmacology
3.
Neurology
3.1
Acetylcholine
In a screening study of Thai herbs, Butea Superba at 0.1mg/mL was able to inhibit acetylcholineasterase in the range of 50-65%, underperforming relative to Tabernaemontana divaricata and Stephania suberosa; all herbs underperformed relative to Galantamine as active control.[8]
May inhibit acetylcholinesterase (and increase acetylcholine as a response) although it underperformed relative to other herbs as well as the active control of Galantamine
4.
Interactions with Organ Systems
4.1
Penis
Butea Superba has been noted to enhance penile erection in rats at a concentration of 0.1-1000mg/mL (in vitro testing on rat penile tissue) where the mean cavernosal pressure increased at 0.1mg/mL (1.7%), 1mg/mL (6.8%), 10mg/mL (4.2%) and 1000mg/mL (8.3%); somewhat following concentration-dependence.[9] When measuring intracavernosal pressure (ICP), a concentration correlating to 1mg/kg was seen as most effective, and the relaxation effect of Butea Superba appeared to be potentiated when incubated with cGMP (a small signalling molecule that is the result of PDE5 inhibition).[9] This penile erection property has been replicated in diabetic rats (diabetes tends to hinder erectile function secondary to poor blood circulation) with 10mg/kg of the ethanolic extract being the most effective dose (relative to 1mg/kg and 100mg/kg, although all were better than control)[10] and although one study has once reported a potency greater than Viagra, it itself failed to replicate these effects.[11]
Butea Superba ethanolic stem extract at 50mcg/mL in vitro was shown to inhibit ROCK-II by 51.83%, with the successive aqueous extract inhibiting 34.85%;[12] this outperformed herbs such as Sphaeranthus Indicus (22.4% and 36.77%, respectively), Chlorophytum Borivilianum (4.11% and 40.54%) and Tribulus Terrestris (20.48% and 10.83%) but greatly underperformed relative to Syzygium Cumini (87.27% and 89.67%) and Terminalia chebula (87.55% and 86.83%).[12]
Has mechanisms to induce penile relaxation
One study in persons with erectile dysfunction using the basic tuber extract at 500mg for a period of 3 months noted that there were improvements in sexual function as reported by IIEF-5 with 82.4% of patients (n=17 overall) reporting either fair or excellent improvement from baseline.[13] This study is highly limited, if not downgraded in importance from double-blind to pilot, as the entire placebo condition dropped out.[13]
In an open-label trial for persons taking 100mg of Butea Superba noted that the proerectile effects of the herb, when taken 1-2 hours before sex, was comparable to the active control of Viagra; when the study was conducted in a double-blind manner using a different batch of Butea Superba, these effects failed to be replicated.[11] The authors noted a higher degree of variation between batches, and stated that blending of PDE5 inhibitors in the first batch caused a false positive.[11]
Preliminary evidence to support the usage of Butea Superba for the use of erectile dysfunction, but literally the entire placebo group dropped out of the first study and the second appears to have faulty product used (with much less remarkable results coming from the later batch)
4.2
Male Reprodutive Organs
When male rats are fed Butea Superba daily for 8 weeks (2mg/kg, 25mg/kg, 250mg/kg, and 1250mg/kg) noted that sperm count was increased approximately 16% at all doses with no dose-dependence noted, and although there appeared to be a trend to increase teste weight only the 1250mg/kg group reached significance.[14]
5.
Interactions with Hormones
5.1
Testosterone
One study hypothesized that Butea Superba has direct androgenic effects, as evidenced by 150-200mg/kg of the root powder causing a dose-dependent decrease in serum testosterone paired with side-effects commonly associated with androgenicity (increased serum ALP and AST; increased spleen weight).[15] These androgenic effects were replicated in female mice.[16]
Limited evidence in support of it, but there is some evidence to suggest that components of Butea Superba have direct androgenic actions
In rats, Butea Superba at oral doses of 10, 50, or 250mg/kg daily for 8 weeks failed to influence circulating testosterone levels[17] although another study noted a dose-dependent decrease above 250mg/kg.[15] When tested in humans, in a sample of persons with erectile dysfunction an increase from 2.751.40ng/mg to 3.061.37ng/mg (11.2%) was observed but deemed to be not statistically significant.[13]
At least one case study has noted a case of hyperandrogenemia associated with Butea Superba supplementation, where a 35 year old man took Butea Superba (unreported dosage) for 'a few weeks' for the purposes of hair regrowth and upon clinical examination his serum DHT was 1512pg/mL (152% of the maximum possible value in the normal range), 328ug/mL DHEAS, 1.7% free testosterone and 43.24pg/mL SHBG.[18] Upon cessation of the herb, DHT and sexual desire normalized at 1 week followup.
Highly unreliable effects on circulating testosterone, with decreases (thought to be secondary to androgenic phytonutrients) and increases (reason unknown) both being reported
5.2
Estrogen
One study noted that there are some weak phytoestrogens (one pterocarpan and isoflavones) contained in Butea Superba with a relative potency (relative to 17β-estradiol) ranging from 5.27-15.5%.[19] Other components (currently unknown) in the extracts of Butea Superba appear to have anti-estrogenic effects against 17β-estradiol when coincubated.[19]
Potential estrogenic and antiestrogenic effects depending on cellular context, practical significance not known
5.3
Luteinizing Hormone
In male rats either sexually intact or without testicles (orchidectomized) it was noted that 50 and 250mg/kg (not 10mg/kg) was able to suppress the increase in Luteinizing Hormone (LH) associated with removal of the testicles; there was no significant effect in intact rats.[17]
6.
Safety and Toxicity
6.1
General
Oral intakes of 1250mg/kg of the tuber to rats for 8 weeks has failed to exert toxic effects,[14] despite this same study making note of a publication (original paper cannot be located) where 360mg/kg injections were lethal via cardiac failure.[14] The Thailand equivalent of the FDA appears to have set the safe limit of this food product at 100mg daily, or 0.2mg per 100g bodyweight (100mg for a 50kg/110lb person).[14]
It has been noted that consumption of high doses of Butea Superba (300mg/kg in rats; human dose of 48mg/kg) may exert genotoxic effects despite lower doses being free from toxicity.[20] This has been noted elsewhere with 1000mg/kg but not 200mg/kg.[21]
Limited evidence all around, but it appears to be safe at low doses (those that seem to be used in nutritional supplementation) although it appears to be mutagenic (causing mutations) at higher doses
Butea Superba is most often used for Men’s Health. The Examine Database covers Male Sexual Dysfunction.
